Okay, I'm even more confused now. I changed IP range , just in case there's a zombie policy somewhere. (firewall is now 192.168.18.1, client in this case is 192.168.18.5. I'm now seeing states on the firewall, for this interface. I also enabled logging, and ran a packet capture.
The firewall log shows regular traffic being allowed, based on the generous allow policy I have.
[image: 1766011483918-screenshot-2025-12-17-165956.png]
The packet capture shows a whole bunch of TCP retransmits, and unanswered SYNs. [image: 1766011544145-45f67d0d-d112-4f05-bf83-4fcb846e79eb-image.png]
I tried a traceroute was suggested, and got timeouts after the firewall.[image: 1766011592684-screenshot-2025-12-17-162013.png]
Lastly, a possible puzzle piece: I found an active but unused gateway, listing opt6 as the interface(!!). I tried disabling then deleting that gateway, but doing so did not seemingly affect the symptoms I'm seeing.